What Should I Fix First on My Website?

What should I fix first on my website

The moment you start looking critically at your website, something interesting happens. You find a problem. Then another. The homepage needs updating. Several photographs are too large. One service page is out of date. The mobile menu isn’t quite right. There are old plugins to investigate, a form you aren’t sure is working and three articles you meant to update months ago.

Before long, your simple website review has become a list of 37 things that apparently need fixing. So where do you start? Not with the easiest item. Not necessarily with the cheapest. And certainly not with the thing that happens to annoy you most. The best place to start is with the problem that creates the greatest obstacle for your customers or your business.

That requires prioritisation.

Not every website problem is equally important

Imagine two problems. The first is that you don’t particularly like the font used for your headings. The second is that your contact form hasn’t delivered an enquiry for three weeks. Both are website issues. Only one should stop everything else. This sounds obvious when the difference is that dramatic, but website decisions are rarely presented so neatly. Perhaps the homepage photographs aren’t quite as professional as you would like. At the same time, one of your most important services doesn’t have its own page.

Which should come first? Maybe you dislike the colour of your buttons, but your opening hours are incorrect. One problem affects your personal preference. The other affects the customer.

That distinction is useful. When deciding what to fix first, ask: “What happens if I don’t fix this?” The answer helps establish the priority.

Start with anything that prevents people accessing the website

Some problems belong at the top of the list because they affect the basic operation of the site. If the website is unavailable, producing security warnings or failing to load important pages, deal with those issues first. The same applies to serious problems affecting mobile users or browsers. There is little point improving your homepage copy if a significant proportion of customers cannot reliably access it. Think of this as the lowest level of your website foundation. Before improving how effectively the website communicates, make sure people can actually use it.

Security, availability and essential functionality aren’t glamorous. They are fundamental.

Next, check whether customers can complete important actions

Once the website is accessible, look at what you need customers to do. For many businesses, that means making contact. For others, it might mean booking an appointment, buying a product, requesting a quotation, subscribing, downloading something or visiting a physical location. Test those processes.

Don’t assume they work because the buttons are visible. Submit the form. Make a test booking. Place a test order if appropriate. Click the telephone number on a mobile device. Check where emails arrive. Follow the process from beginning to end.

If the website successfully attracts potential customers but the final action fails, fixing that problem should take priority over almost everything cosmetic. The closer a problem sits to an important business outcome, the more seriously you should treat it. Correct information that could mislead customers.

The next priority is accuracy. A beautifully designed website containing incorrect information is still a poor website. Check your telephone number, email address, opening hours, location and service areas. Then look at prices, product information, team members and service descriptions. Has anything changed? Could somebody make a decision based on information that is no longer true? This matters because incorrect information doesn’t simply inconvenience customers. It damages trust.

If somebody arrives at your premises because the website says you are open and discovers you are closed, they don’t experience that as a website maintenance problem. They experience it as a problem with the business. Accuracy should therefore come before polishing.

Look for the places where customers are getting stuck

Once the critical problems have been dealt with, move from what is broken? to what is difficult? This requires thinking about the website as a journey. Suppose visitors regularly reach a service page but very few continue to the enquiry stage. Why? Perhaps the service isn’t explained clearly enough. Maybe there is no obvious next step. The customer might need pricing information, examples of previous work or answers to common questions before they feel comfortable contacting you.

Perhaps the page works perfectly from a technical perspective but doesn’t give people enough confidence to continue. These problems can be harder to identify because nothing is visibly broken. The page loads. The buttons work. The content exists. Yet the website isn’t helping the customer progress.

This is where customer behaviour, analytics and direct feedback can become useful.

Fix clarity before decoration

Business owners understandably want their websites to look professional. Visual presentation contributes to trust. But when time or budget is limited, clarity usually deserves priority over decoration. If a visitor cannot understand what you do, changing the font isn’t going to solve the problem. If your main service is buried three levels down in the navigation, a new colour palette won’t make it easier to find. If the homepage doesn’t explain who you help, replacing the hero photograph may improve the appearance without improving the message.

Before redesigning, ask whether the problem is actually visual. Sometimes what appears to be an old-looking page simply lacks structure. Clearer headings, better organisation and stronger content may transform it without requiring a complete redesign.

Pay attention to your most important pages first

Not every page deserves equal attention. Your website may contain dozens or hundreds of pages, but a relatively small number may be responsible for most customer activity.

The homepage is an obvious candidate, but don’t automatically assume it is the most important. A particular service page may receive significant search traffic. A popular article could introduce large numbers of new visitors to the business. A booking page may be responsible for most conversions. An ecommerce business may depend heavily on a small number of product or category pages.

Identify the pages that matter most to customer journeys and commercial outcomes. Improving an important page by 20% may be far more valuable than perfecting ten pages almost nobody visits. This is one of the reasons website analytics can be useful. They help move decisions away from guesswork.

Don’t ignore pages that should be important but aren’t

There is a catch. If you only look at your most visited pages, you can miss an important problem. Imagine one of your core services receives almost no website traffic. You might conclude that the page isn’t important. But perhaps the opposite is true. The service is commercially important, yet the page is difficult to find, poorly optimised or barely mentioned elsewhere on the website.

Low traffic can sometimes be evidence of the problem rather than a reason to ignore the page. Combine data with business knowledge. Ask which pages should matter, not simply which ones currently receive attention. Separate urgent work from important work. Website improvement lists often become difficult because everything ends up in one place.

A broken checkout appears alongside “replace team photograph” and “rewrite About page.” It helps to separate problems into different levels of priority. Urgent issues are things that create security problems, prevent access, stop customers completing important actions or provide seriously incorrect information. High-priority improvements remove significant barriers, improve important customer journeys or address problems on commercially valuable pages.

Then there are worthwhile improvements: better content, stronger imagery, clearer layouts, improved internal links and other changes that make the website progressively better.

Finally, there are preferences. The things you would like to change because you personally prefer a different style. Preferences are allowed. They just shouldn’t automatically jump ahead of problems affecting customers.

Consider effort as well as impact

Priority isn’t only about importance. Effort matters too. Suppose you identify two improvements. One could make an important service page considerably clearer and take 30 minutes. Another might improve performance slightly but require several days of development. You don’t necessarily need to choose one forever.

But the quick, high-impact improvement is an obvious candidate to complete first. This is where website improvement becomes much more manageable. Instead of asking whether you can afford to fix the entire website, identify changes that create meaningful improvements for reasonable effort. Some will take minutes. Others may become larger projects requiring professional support.

Both can belong on the same improvement plan without needing to happen at the same time.

Be careful with changes that affect several other things

Not every website improvement should be made immediately just because it appears useful. Some changes have wider consequences. Changing website URLs can affect existing links and search visibility. Replacing a theme can alter layouts across the entire site. Removing plugins may affect functionality you didn’t realise depended on them. Changing a booking system could disrupt existing processes. This is where fixing things can accidentally create new problems.

Before making significant technical changes, understand what else they affect. Take appropriate backups. Record existing settings. And when necessary, get specialist help.

A strong foundation isn’t created by changing things quickly. It is created by changing the right things carefully.

Make one meaningful improvement and measure again

There is another advantage to prioritising website work. You can see what makes a difference. If you redesign the website, change the navigation, rewrite every page, install several plugins and replace the contact form at the same time, it becomes difficult to know which changes helped. Smaller, deliberate improvements make learning easier. Improve the service page. Then observe what happens. Simplify the contact form. Test it. Optimise the largest images. Measure performance again.

This approach turns website maintenance from a periodic crisis into an ongoing improvement process. The website doesn’t need to remain untouched for five years and then be completely rebuilt. It can evolve with the business.

Create a website priority test

When you find something you want to change, ask yourself a few simple questions. Does this affect whether people can access or safely use the website? Does it prevent a customer completing an important action? Is the information wrong or misleading? Does it create confusion or unnecessary friction? Does it affect an important page, service or source of business? How much effort will it take to improve? What is likely to happen if I leave it alone? You don’t need a complicated scoring system.

The questions simply force you to think about impact before action. That helps prevent website work being driven by whichever issue happened to catch your attention that morning.

Your website doesn’t need to be perfect

This is perhaps the most useful thing to remember. There will almost always be something you could improve. A sentence could be rewritten. A photograph could be better. A page could load slightly faster. Another article could be published. A button could be moved.

If perfection becomes the objective, website improvement never ends. Within the Foundation pillar of The DEFRAG Framework, the objective is not to create a website with nothing left to improve. It is to build and maintain a digital foundation that reliably supports the business. So when the list becomes overwhelming, don’t ask: “How am I going to fix all of this?” Ask: “Which problem is creating the greatest obstacle for my customers or my business right now?” Start there.

Fix the things that are broken before the things that are unattractive. Fix customer barriers before personal preferences. Prioritise important journeys and commercially valuable pages. Then review the website again.

There will probably still be plenty you could change. That’s fine. Choose the next improvement that matters. And continue.

One piece at a time.

Discover more articles here

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *